diff --git a/pub/proposal/proposal.pdf b/pub/proposal/proposal.pdf index a31220a..da49732 100644 Binary files a/pub/proposal/proposal.pdf and b/pub/proposal/proposal.pdf differ diff --git a/pub/proposal/proposal.tex b/pub/proposal/proposal.tex index 65c342e..48ea01a 100644 --- a/pub/proposal/proposal.tex +++ b/pub/proposal/proposal.tex @@ -2,6 +2,8 @@ \usepackage{csquotes} +\usepackage{xcolor} + % Tables \usepackage{tabularx} \usepackage{booktabs} @@ -31,6 +33,10 @@ } } +\newcommand{\lfcomment}[1]{\textcolor{blue}{\textbf{LF}:~#1}} +%Uncomment below to remove comments from PDF yet keeping in the LaTeX :-) +%\renewcommand{\lfcomment}[1]{\relax} + \begin{document} % Title Page and contents \begin{titlepage} @@ -46,7 +52,8 @@ \begin{itemize} \item Designing Emergency Checklists is difficult \item Procedures in checklists must be tested in simulators~\cite{nasa-design}, - which usally means trained pilots test it + which usually means trained pilots test it + \lfcomment{Testing for what? What's the baseline? I guess you will need some kind of evidence/argument that demonstrates that with and without the checklist results are markedly different. } \item Checklists are usually carried out in high workload environments, especially emergency ones \end{itemize} @@ -55,17 +62,20 @@ \begin{itemize} \item Testing procedures in checklists are often neglected~\cite{nasa-design} \item There are some checklists that may not be fit - for certain scenarios + for certain scenarios \lfcomment{What check lists and what scenarios?} \item Some checklists may make pilots \enquote{stuck} + \lfcomment{Yes, or might make them ignore the checklist. What criteria does that?} \item Checklists may take too long to carry out - Swissair 111 + \lfcomment{Yes. See Checklist manifesto test} \end{itemize} \subsubsection*{Rationale} \begin{itemize} - \item Test checklists in a simulated environment + \item Test checklists in a simulated environment \lfcomment{Again, explain testing against what} \item Results in being able to see where to improve checklists \end{itemize} +\lfcomment{On CL book, Ch1 is about nature of where CL work best; Ch2 explains what a CL is and isn't; Ch3 you can ignore, it talks about checklist for unknown/unexpected scenarios (advanced CL) in building; Ch4 he discussed CL with chefs; Ch5 talks about CL failures and why; \textbf{Ch6 is about Boeing's CL ``factory''}; Ch7 and 8 are about applying the CL he came up with, here you get the examples of test/baseline criteria for CL; Ch9 he explains it in his own practice (this is daunting read)!.} \subsection{Key Background Sources} \begin{tabularx}{\linewidth}{p{8em} X} \toprule @@ -110,6 +120,8 @@ \item Find how reproducible the checklist is \end{enumerate} +\lfcomment{See above about "testing" what?} + \subsection*{Objectives} \begin{enumerate} \item Checklist Manager @@ -122,11 +134,12 @@ \item Capture state of aircraft \item Simulate a pilot's actions \item Simulate delay in actions + \lfcomment{\item Ensure consistency of checklist logic} \end{enumerate} \item Simulator connector \begin{enumerate} \item Connect to the flight simulator - \item Set up conditions of flight + \item Set up conditions for flight \item Monitor and take Logic's actions \end{enumerate} \end{enumerate}